We know we’re not alone in having a constant daydream of getting to kiss one of the One Direction boys. We wouldn’t be too picky about which one it was because all of them are beyond adorable. But we imagine the fantasy kiss would be super romantic. Like, fairytale romantic. Definitely not goofy and silly and super surprising.

The boys of 1D visited The Late Show with David Letterman and one of them got a kiss that wasn’t, well, all that romantic. We don’t want to give it away, so you’ll have to check out the clip above to see which Directioner gets a big ol’ smooch from actor Dustin Hoffman.

What do YOU think? Tell us in the comments and on Twitter!