Aria Montgomery at Riverdale High!?

After an exciting exchange between Lucy Hale and Madelaine Petsch on Instagram, fans are speculating that there’s about to be a new addition to the Riverdale cast. Hey, we’re not complaining!

Lucy, who’s no stranger to acting in a spooky teen mystery-drama, commented on Madelaine’s Instagram photo, wishing that she was in it, and the actress behind Cheryl Bloom responded, “@lucyhale we shall recreate when ur here.”

Does that mean that Lucy is on her way!? Only time will tell!

Here’s the pic that sparked the rumor:

put your leg up on my hip, when you dip I dip we dip

A post shared by Madelaine Petsch (@madelame) on

Want more behind-the-scenes pics from all your favorite Riverdale cast members? Season 2 is in full swing and they’re not holding back!

More TigerBeat!

placeholder
Quiz: Which TV Show Sums Up Your Summer?

Quiz: Which TV Show Sums Up Your Summer?

placeholder
Marvel Teases an On-Screen Zendaya and Tom Holland Romance

Marvel Teases an On-Screen Zendaya and Tom Holland Romance

placeholder
Sarah Hyland Reveals Her ‘Shadowhunters’ Character!

Sarah Hyland Reveals Her ‘Shadowhunters’ Character!