This is Why Fans Think Lucy Hale Will Star in Riverdale

Aria Montgomery at Riverdale High!?

After an exciting exchange between Lucy Hale and Madelaine Petsch on Instagram, fans are speculating that there’s about to be a new addition to the Riverdale cast. Hey, we’re not complaining!

Lucy, who’s no stranger to acting in a spooky teen mystery-drama, commented on Madelaine’s Instagram photo, wishing that she was in it, and the actress behind Cheryl Bloom responded, “@lucyhale we shall recreate when ur here.”

Does that mean that Lucy is on her way!? Only time will tell!

Here’s the pic that sparked the rumor:

put your leg up on my hip, when you dip I dip we dip

A post shared by Madelaine Petsch (@madelame) on Jul 13, 2017 at 12:55pm PDT

Want more behind-the-scenes pics from all your favorite Riverdale cast members? Season 2 is in full swing and they’re not holding back!