Halloween might still be a month away, but your favorite boy band is already planning their costumes!

PRETTYMUCH, who recently released their first-ever music video, took to Twitter with a selfie captioned “should we be the justice league for halloween,” and we definitely vote yes!

The only problem? The justice league has seven members — Superman, Aquaman, Flash, Green Lantern, Martian Manhunter, Batman and Wonder Woman — and PRETTYMUCH only has five. It sounds like the boys might need two more to tag along with them this trick or treating season!

A few of PRETTYMUCH’s nearly 30K followers were totally on board, but others had a few ideas of their own. Keep scrolling to check out some of our favorite fan reactions:

Want to know more about PRETTYMUCH? We’ve got all the details!

More TigerBeat!

placeholder
Camila Cabello Slays The BRITS 2018 Red Carpet

Camila Cabello Slays The BRITS 2018 Red Carpet

placeholder
Eva Gutowski Slays in New Valentines Day Photoshoot

Eva Gutowski Slays in New Valentines Day Photoshoot

placeholder
Quiz: Finish the Lyric – ‘Smiles for You’ by Hayden Summerall

Quiz: Finish the Lyric – ‘Smiles for You’ by Hayden Summerall